Ruling could come any day; decision will impact several Revere residents

By Seth Daniel

[email protected]

At one time, the Massachusetts Turnpike Authority was a simple toll-collecting agency, but now it has attracted the ire of many tollpayers and has prompted a lawsuit that many in Revere and the surrounding areas are joining.

Beverly Attorney Jan Schlichtmann filed a class action lawsuit in Middlesex Superior Court (in Woburn) against the Pike last May, and this month, there have been several court dates. A decision is believed to be imminent. The case has signed on 2,300 plaintiffs who all agree that they are being unfairly singled out to pay for Big Dig debt.

In Revere, Nick and Elena Carangelo of Fowler Avenue are two of those who have signed on, and said that they feel abused by the Pike and its practices.

“I think it’s an outrage, and I hope that all the residents of Revere, East Boston and Winthrop, especially senior citizens join in,” said Elena Carangelo. “I and my husband are senior citizens. It has taken its toll on us. It really has.”

Schlictmann said the goal of the lawsuit is to stop the Pike from continuing its inequitable practices and to reward tollpayers for the alleged abuses of the past.

“This is caused by a Big Dig mentality which lives in the Turnpike Authority and, unfortunately, the executive branch is not doing anything to end this Big Dig culture,” he said. “It’s a way of treating people…with such disdain that you can do whatever you want, take whatever you want, and that is okay. The tollpayers have had enough.”

Schlictmann said the movement that created the lawsuit sprang from a grass roots organization that became coordinated by the Internet, where tollpayers continue to sign on to the suit even now.

He explained he took the case because he began doing his research and found that the numbers didn’t add up.

As part of tollpayer relief, the state government gave the Pike $100 million on July 1. Combined with other non-toll revenue, the Pike had $157 million in its budget outside of tolls.

They said they needed $268 million to run the Authority.

Meanwhile, Schlictmann said, the Authority also planned on collecting every penny they could from the tollpayers, some $172 million, instead of giving them a break.

“They’ll have more than $40 million extra,” he said. “Why do they need $40 million more than they said they needed? …The numbers don’t add up, and it shows they don’t care about the tollpayers and they don’t care about fairness. They should be talking about reducing tolls in 2010, but instead, they’re talking about increasing them.

“They’re saying they will take all the taxpayer money and all the toll money too,” he said.

Another problem that Schlictmann identified is the inequity tollpayers faced, especially those in Revere and north of Boston. Of those that use the Metropolitan Highway System (including the Turnpike Authority, the Sumner Callahan tunnels, the Williams Tunnel and Interstate 93), he said only a few of them pay tolls.

By his numbers, some 632,000 people use those roads each weekday, and only 288,000 pass through a toll facility. That means 344,000 aren’t paying for the system.

“That means that 288,000 people are paying a fee for their use and they’re using all toll money to finance Big Dig debt,” he said. “Our North Shore contingent is one of our most valuable assets. They feel it intensely and are really singled out for abusive conduct.”

If the suit works out the way that he and tollpayers hope, he said there would be a settlement, and anyone signed onto the lawsuit who is a tollpayer would be able to recover some money. The ruling would also move things forward in a more equitable way, especially when the Turnpike is phased out on November 1.

He said in no way do they wish to make things more difficult for other commuters who aren’t paying a toll right now.

“There are all sorts of ways to make the past right,” he said. “We intend to sit down and figure out what can be done about the past.”

To sign onto the lawsuit, one can visit or write to Toll Equity Trust, P.O. Box 40, Southborough, MA 01772.

6 comments for “Ruling could come any day; decision will impact several Revere residents

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.